• Home
  • About Me
  • Comment Policy
  • Perfume Reviews by House

Muse in Wooden Shoes

A blog about stuff that interests me:: perfume, novels, poetry, family, etc….

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Scent Diary, July 18-24, 2011
I’m Baaaaaaack! »

Fragrance Throwdown: Ferre by Ferre versus Gianfranco Ferre (2005)

July 26, 2011 by malsnano86

Photo of wrestlers via Wikimedia Commons

I went looking for these in the first place because of Iris Poudre. I had read in comments on a ‘fume blog that Ferre by Ferre was a close cousin of Iris Poudre, which I love. Then there’s a review of Gianfranco Ferre in Perfumes: The Guide stating that it is a more-polished, fully-developed version of Iris Poudre. However, I’m still not absolutely convinced that the confusingly similar names of the Ferre fragrances haven’t caused a mixup in at least one case. Here are my thoughts on the matter, developed through multiple wearings and side-by-side comparisons over several months, as well as some good old-fashioned internet research. I confess that I’m still puzzled by the P:TG review.

(In case you are wondering, “old-fashioned internet research” was a joke. A terrible joke, but nonetheless.)

Both fragrances tested are minis acquired on ebay, with Ferre by Ferre in the black hand-grenade bottle (also produced as a goldtone mesh hand-grenade) and Gianfranco Ferre in the rectangular Ferre bottle, the same shape as my golden Ferre 20 bottle except clear glass with gold top. (see pix) This was the other blog comment that kicked up my interest in these Ferre fragrances: Commenter Melissa on Perfume Posse: “I am also amassing bottles of a few of the entirely underrated discontinued Ferres. Specifically, the older Ferre by Ferre (“classic”) in the round grenade shaped bottle, a modern floral aldehyde. And Ferre 20, a floral with a rich, woody-vanillic base. The latter has become crazy expensive, if you can find it at all.” That was the reason I was so happy to snag that bottle of Ferre 20 in Rome – well, that recommendation, and the fact that I think it smells great.

I warn you now – if you hate aldehydes, these two are not going to change your mind. But if you like them, these are both enjoyable and attractive fragrances, and the 2005 version is still available at a reasonable price at discounters (currently selling at FragranceX at about $37 for a 50ml bottle).

Ferre by Ferre from Fragrantica

Notes for Ferre by Ferre: Top Aldehydes, orange, green notes, peach, neroli, bergamot, lemon. Heart Mimosa, passionfruit, carnation, violet, orange blossom, ivy, jasmine, ylang-ylang, lily of the valley, rose, oakmoss. Base Spices, orris root, sandalwood, tonka bean, amber, musk, benzoin, vanilla, vetiver, styrax.

It reminds me more of Le Labo Aldehydes 44 than of Iris Poudre, but I can see the IP reference. It never develops IP’s delicious, angora-fluff benzoin drydown, though.

In fact, nothing does, so far as I have been able to find out. My opinion is that Iris Poudre got robbed in Luca Turin’s three-star P:TG review, which states, in part, “Simply stated, the problem with iris-root smell is this: everyone loves its gray, nostalgic, romantic powderiness, but the stuff is, truth be told, as funereal as it gets… [Pierre Bourdon’s] expertise in making resolutely sunny, fruity compositions very quickly dries iris’ tears. After a restrained initial gravitas appropriate to the occasion, Iris Poudre veers toward a happier disposition reminiscent of Bourdon’s Dolce Vita… A good fragrance, but not true to its name or material.”

I’ll concur, Iris Poudre isn’t all that iris-y. Which is fine with me, for to be honest I am not the World’s Biggest Iris Fan. And true, it’s sunny and fruity; this is also fine with me because I like Dolce Vita very much. I would, however, quibble with the assertion that IP is “powdery.” It isn’t all that powdery; rather, it is as fluffy as a marabou stole.

Okay, true: I admit that I got pretty snarky about Elizabeth Taylor’s Violet Eyes having violet in the packaging, violet in the name, but no violet in the fragrance – but it is after all a very attractive floral that I might have bought if it had been just a little more distinctive. Dr. Turin gets similarly snarky when a fragrance name references either gardenia or iris, and turns out to not have much of whatever’s advertised, so I can’t blame him all that much. All the same, here I am looking for an Iris Poudre clone because I love it so much and it’s so expensive, and I still haven’t found one. Various fragrances replicate pieces of it – Ferre by Ferre and Ulric de Varens pour Elle mimic the sweet aldehydic top, Dolce Vita and Ferre 20 do the fruity bit, and Mariella Burani does something close to IP’s wonderful drydown. An all-of-a-piece replica? Doesn’t exist.

As a matter of fact, Ferre by Ferre happens to be discontinued and very difficult to find. Minis still float around on ebay, and I know of at least one fragrance seller on ebay that has a bottle or two of it, at approximately $100 for a 100ml bottle.   However, it’s still not all that much less expensive than a bottle of IP, so I’m still totally stuck on that “find a replacement for Iris Poudre” quest.

Ferre by Gianfranco Ferre (edp) from Fragrantica

After the fun start, GF turns into floral soap for some time, prim and opaque, flat as a piece of Sheetrock. The contrast with the sparkly topnotes is drastic. I don’t get a lot of iris in it, nor much rose. What does pop out, to my nose, is the lemony-creamy note of magnolia, and a sullen pouty jasmine, with just a hint of sugared violets. The drydown – primarily woody-musky-vanilla – is very comfortable, and easy to wear, though sweetened with amber.  It lasts well, about four hours on me (dabbed).  In my opinion, GF seems very little like Iris Poudre, despite the same perfumer and what is claimed to be a similar structure.

Notes for Gianfranco Ferre: Top Pineapple, melon, iris leaf, bergamot, [aldehydes]. Heart Magnolia, iris, freesia, jasmine, ylang-ylang, violet, rose. Base sandalwood, amber, basmati rice, musk, vanilla, orris root.

Now here’s Tania Sanchez, reviewing this fragrance (referred to as Ferre from the house of Gianfranco Ferre) and giving it four stars where Iris Poudre received three: “Five years after doing Iris Poudre… Bourdon polished the idea for Ferre. Slightly more vegetal than the Malle fragrance, Ferre is nevertheless a close match: powdery, woody-sweet in a violet way, and slightly too bright, like overexposed flash photographs.”

I admit here that I am not at all sure that I’m smelling the same fragrance that TS was reviewing. The notes list for this scent seems congruent with what I’m smelling – the fruit in particular, which TS doesn’t even mention, is prominent. “Powdery” is not at all a phrase I’d use to describe what I’m smelling here. Neither does “too bright.” This thing seems sort of dense to me, and, yes, sweet. It’s a fruity sweetness, but it’s true that sometimes violets (ionones) can seem fruity and sweet.  I am totally Not Getting the Iris Poudre reference, not in the least bit.  I noticed, too late, that my miniature bottle is Eau de Toilette, while the larger bottles are Eau de Parfum, and that may be the  issue.  Please weigh in if you’ve tried both the EdT and the EdP – and if you think I have the wrong one!

Over on Fragrantica, I notice that people keep putting reviews on the wrong Ferre fragrances. Someone has done a long, thoughtful review of the original 1984 Ferre fragrance, a rich floral oriental, on the 2005 Gianfranco Ferre scent. (FAIL!) Someone else has posted a lovely review of GF on Ferre by Ferre; I know it’s GF because it mentions a strong presence of fruit. Aargh. I think we have to blame Gianfranco Ferre himself for that. Was there ever another designer so enamored of his own name?! (Well, maybe. But nobody else has committed the marketing mistake of confusing potential customers with similar-sounding fragrances.)

A few other blog reviews of the Gianfranco Ferre fragrance: Bois de Jasmin and Legerdenez.  Enjoy.

Once again, we have a Throwdown where the winner is decided on points: While I think the 2005 Bourdon fragrance is a good one, a lighthearted sweet fruity floral with aldehydes and vanilla, I prefer the older fragrance, the hand-grenade bottle one, much more. It’s much softer, a pleasant powdery veil.  I might actually prefer Ferre 20 to either one of these, but they’re both lovely.

Share this:

  • Print
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in aldehydic floral, Fragrance Throwdown, Fruity floral, Gianfranco Ferre | Tagged Fragrance Throwdown, Gianfranco Ferre perfume | 9 Comments

9 Responses

  1. on July 27, 2011 at 3:09 PM Ann

    Hi, lady — great post. Those both sound lovely, but I definitely second you on the major name confusion. Sheesh! Don’t know how you kept it all straight.
    Can’t wait to try the 20, though.
    BTW, I know Iris Poudre is your No. 1 iris, but am curious what’s your No. 2, if there is one. Take care …


    • on July 31, 2011 at 7:09 PM malsnano86

      Very, very confusing names!

      I would actually say that No. 19 is my top iris, as I absolutely adore Iris Poudre but I would not call it an irisy scent. I am not much of a fan of iris-heavy scents, and was surprised at how pleasant I found Iris Silver Mist.


  2. on July 28, 2011 at 10:17 AM anotherperfumeblog

    I’m sort of echoing Ann’s question. I’m curious what other irises you like, because I’m interested in smelling some more, and “sunnier” irises sound like fun. I have to admit I never got a terribly optimistic feeling from Iris Poudre, but I still like it and agree that three stars is pretty harsh.


    • on July 31, 2011 at 7:13 PM malsnano86

      Oh, I think IP is cheerful! The adjective that comes to mind most for it is “fluffy” – I really, really love the drydown.

      But as I just said to Ann, IP is not very irisy. No. 19 rocks, and indeed any Chanel has got a ton of iris. I like PG Iris Taizo (which may or may not have been renamed Iris Oriental), too. Hated Hiris. Hated the expensive limited edition L’Artisan Iris Pallida. It seems that I really prefer my iris to be an accent, not the focus.


  3. on July 28, 2011 at 10:18 AM anotherperfumeblog

    That was a very me-centered comment. I would also like to say I enjoyed this throwdown very much. 🙂


    • on July 31, 2011 at 7:13 PM malsnano86

      Well, thanks!


  4. on August 1, 2011 at 5:04 AM waftbycarolrol

    I enjoyed your comparison’s very much , although I have never sniffed the Ferre scents , I love iris Poudre too .
    As far as Turin and Sanchez , I have never read any of their book , the sense of smell is far too subjective to listen to a word they have to say . From quotes I have read , neither one of them knows a good fragrance when they smell it , their olfactory bulbs exploded ages ago after too much mainstream dreck fried their nose hairs . jus sayin’…
    I completely respect Turin and the research he has done postulating his vibration theory applied to the sense of smell , and I think it is spot on .
    Sanchez , I never agree with a thing she says .
    Gosh , that was rather opinionated , but I feel so much better now . hehe .


    • on August 1, 2011 at 8:00 PM malsnano86

      Thanks! Iris Poudre is so gorgeous.

      Oh, I actually love reading P:TG… even when I don’t agree with the authors (pretty often), it’s a great fun read, and frequently there’s something in the book that points out some relationship between two scents that I didn’t realize before. I keep a teaspoon of salt next to it, but I do enjoy the book.


      • on August 1, 2011 at 8:14 PM Ann

        I hear Carol about LT and TS, sometimes they do make me go “What?!!”
        But the Guide can be quite entertaining. A teaspoon of salt next to it is probably a smart move …



Comments are closed.

  • Wooden shoes tied with ribbon

    by creating in the dark at flickr

  • Why do the Graces?

    Why do the Graces now desert the Muse?
    They hate bright ribbons tying wooden shoes.
    (Walter Savage Landor)

    My work may be wooden shoes, but it will be wearing those bright ribbons anyway.

  • Recent Posts

    • Moving Back!
    • The moving truck is loaded up!
    • Tuesday Roundup: Serge Lutens Mini-reviews, Part 3
    • Scent Diary, Jan. 2 – 8, 2012
    • Tuberose Series Perfume Review #21: Amouage Honour Woman
  • Blog Stats

    • 339,846 hits
  • Categories

    • aldehydic floral
    • Amouage
    • Annick Goutal
    • Applause
    • Balenciaga
    • Balmain
    • Bath and Body Works
    • Blog housecleaning
    • book review
    • Bvlgari
    • By Kilian
    • Caron
    • Chanel
    • Chloe
    • chypres
    • Citrus scents
    • Clean scents
    • Coty
    • Create
    • Crown Perfumery
    • Dark Rose
    • Diane Von Furstenberg
    • Dior
    • Diptyque
    • Discontinued
    • Drawing
    • DSH Perfumes
    • Elizabeth Taylor
    • Estee Lauder
    • FAIL
    • Family
    • farm
    • fashion
    • Fendi
    • floral chypre
    • Floral oriental
    • Florals
    • Fragrance Throwdown
    • fragrant gifts
    • Frederic Malle
    • Fruity floral
    • Gianfranco Ferre
    • Giorgio
    • Gourmand scents
    • Green scents
    • Gucci
    • Guerlain
    • Hanae Mori
    • Harvey Prince
    • history
    • Holiday
    • Honore des Pres
    • i Profumi di Firenze
    • Il Profumo
    • Jean Desprez
    • Joint Blog Project
    • Kai
    • Karl Lagerfeld
    • L'Artisan
    • Lancome
    • Lanvin
    • Laura Mercier
    • Le Labo
    • Les Nez
    • Literature
    • Literature review
    • Liz Zorn
    • Lucien LeLong
    • Maison Francis Kurkdjian
    • Mariella Burani
    • Mary Greenwell
    • Mauboussin
    • Michael Storer
    • modern chypres
    • Moschino
    • music
    • NaNoWriMo
    • natural perfumery
    • Nobile 1942
    • Novel excerpt
    • Oriental
    • Ormonde Jayne
    • Oscar de la Renta
    • Packaging
    • Parfumerie Generale
    • Parfums de Nicolai
    • Parfums DelRae
    • Parfums Divine
    • Penhaligon's
    • Perfume review
    • Rant
    • Recipe
    • Recipes
    • Rochas
    • Rose chypre
    • Rose scents
    • Scent Diary
    • Seasonal picks
    • Serge Lutens
    • Shiseido
    • Smell Bent
    • Soliflores
    • Sonoma Scent Studio
    • Tauer Perfumes
    • Teo Cabanel
    • That's Just My Opinion
    • The scented life
    • Tom Ford
    • Travel
    • Tuberose scents
    • Ulric de Varens
    • Uncategorized
    • Vanilla scents
    • Victoria's Secret
    • Vintage
    • violet scents
    • White floral
    • Woody
  • Archives

    • November 2019
    • January 2012
    • December 2011
    • November 2011
    • October 2011
    • September 2011
    • August 2011
    • July 2011
    • June 2011
    • May 2011
    • April 2011
    • March 2011
    • February 2011
    • January 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
  • 30 days, 50,000 words = Novel!

  • Beauty and Perfume Blogs

    • Beauty on the Outside
    • Eau MG
    • The Non Blonde
  • Independent Perfumery Blogs

    • DSH Notebook
    • Sonoma Scent Studio
    • Tauer Perfumes
  • Other-than-Perfume Blogs

    • AGtually
    • Cake Wrecks
    • FLYlady
    • Help! I Need a Publisher!
    • Madwoman in the Forest (Laurie Halse Andersen)
    • NaNoWriMo
    • Notes From the Trail
    • Stuff Christians Like
    • Wardrobe Oxygen
  • Perfume Blogs

    • All I Am – A Redhead
    • Another Perfume Blog
    • Bloody Frida
    • Bois de Jasmin
    • Bonkers About Perfume
    • Chicken Freak's Obsessions
    • Eiderdown Press
    • Feminine Things
    • Grain de Musc
    • I Smell Therefore I Am
    • Katie Puckrik Smells
    • Memory of Scent
    • Notes From Josephine
    • Notes from the Ledge
    • Now Smell This
    • Olfactarama
    • Olfactoria's Travels
    • One Thousand Scents
    • Parfumieren
    • Pere de Pierre
    • Perfume Patter
    • Perfume Posse
    • Perfume Shrine
    • Perfume-Smellin' Things
    • Persolaise
    • Redolent of Spices
    • Scent of the Day
    • Scents of Self
    • ScentSate
    • That Smell
    • The Alembicated Genie (Formerly Scent Less Sensibilities)
    • This Blog Really Stinks
    • Undina's Looking Glass
    • WAFT by Carol
    • Yesterday's Perfume
  • Perfume Blogs (informational and/or technical)

    • 1000 Fragrances
  • Perfume Blogs (updated infrequently)

    • Confessions of a perfume nerd
    • Fragrance Bouquet
    • Hortus Conclusus
    • MossyLoomings
    • My Perfume Life (formerly Signature Scent)
    • Punkrockperfumeparty
    • The Left Coast Nose
    • The Unseen Censer
    • Vintage Perfume Vault
  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.com

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Muse in Wooden Shoes
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Muse in Wooden Shoes
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: